New Milford, NJ may be a quiet suburb in Bergen County, but its food scene is anything but sleepy. From handcrafted pizzas to Cuban classics and fresh sushi rolls, the town has built a loyal local following around its diverse and flavorful dining options. Whether you’re planning a quick bite, a family dinner, or a casual brunch, this town has restaurants that know how to feed a craving.

Here’s your ultimate guide to the top restaurants in New Milford NJ, complete with must-visit pizzerias, takeout joints, and neighborhood gems that residents swear by.

 Pizza & Italian: Comfort Food Royalty in New Milford

Roman Pizza & Restaurant

84 Main St, New Milford, NJ 07646
Ask around about pizza in New Milford NJ and you’ll hear the same name over and over—Roman Pizza. Whether you’re picking up a slice or sitting down for a full Italian dinner at Roman Pizza & Restaurant New Milford NJ 07646, expect thin crust, flavorful sauce, and a warm family-run vibe. Regulars refer to it affectionately as Romans in New Milford NJ.

Soprano’s Pizzeria

854 River Rd, New Milford, NJ 07646
Craving a slice with crispy edges and rich cheese pulls? Sopranos Pizza New Milford NJ doesn’t disappoint. Whether you call it Sopranos Pizzeria or just Sopranos New Milford NJ, the result is the same—hot, satisfying pizza with a side of community charm.

 Latin & Cuban Flavor You Won’t Forget

Casual Habana Cafe

200 Main St, New Milford, NJ 07646
One of the town’s culinary standouts, Casual Habana Cafe New Milford NJ delivers authentic Cuban plates in a cozy setting. From ropa vieja to plantain-heavy lunch combos, it’s a go-to Cuban restaurant in New Milford NJ for both locals and Bergen County foodies.

Pancho’s Burritos

214 Main St, New Milford, NJ 07646
If your hunger leans more Tex-Mex, Pancho Burrito New Milford NJ is the stop. Known for oversized burritos and sizzling fajitas, Panchos in New Milford NJ keeps it bold and spicy. Want to preview the feast? Just pull up the Pancho Burrito New Milford NJ menu online and prepare your appetite.

 Sushi & Asian Cuisine: Small Town, Big Flavor

Sushi Story

840 River Rd, New Milford, NJ 07646
A standout in the local sushi scene, Sushi Story New Milford NJ offers beautifully plated rolls, BYOB options, and cozy indoor seating. Whether you’re new to sushi or a seasoned aficionado, this spot consistently ranks among the best sushi in New Milford NJ.

Lantern Chinese Take Out

228 Main St, New Milford, NJ 07646
Consistently dependable, Lantern Chinese New Milford NJ has all your favorite dishes—from sesame chicken to wonton soup. Locals looking for Chinese food in New Milford NJ know Lantern is fast, flavorful, and always satisfying.

China Wok

762 River Rd, New Milford, NJ 07646
Another reliable takeout staple, China Wok New Milford NJ is known for generous portions and quick service. Perfect for weeknight dinners or lunch on the go.

 Casual Bites, Donuts & Delis That Locals Love

Barrel & Brew

826 River Rd, New Milford, NJ 07646
Bar-style bites, burgers, and flatbreads make Barrel and Brew New Milford NJ a great stop for after-work hangouts or weekend meetups. The beer list isn’t bad either.

Big Jim’s

142 Main St, New Milford, NJ 07646
Part pizzeria, part diner, Big Jim’s New Milford NJ is known for its huge portions and classic American-Italian comfort food. A no-fuss neighborhood staple.

Glaze Donuts

358 River Rd, New Milford, NJ 07646
Looking for glazed donuts in New Milford NJ that go beyond the basics? Glaze Donuts delivers creative flavors like maple bacon and Nutella-stuffed delights.

New Milford Delis & United Meat Market

Local delis like New Milford Delicatessen NJ and United Meat Market New Milford NJ are the heart of the town’s quick-lunch culture. These spots serve hot sandwiches, cold cuts, and friendly faces at the counter.

FAQs

Q1: What are the best restaurants in New Milford NJ for pizza?
Roman Pizza and Soprano’s Pizzeria are top choices with loyal followings for their crusts, sauces, and old-school charm.

Q2: Where can I get authentic Cuban or Latin food in New Milford NJ?
Casual Habana Cafe and Pancho’s Burritos are the go-to spots for Cuban plates and Mexican-style burritos.

Q3: Are there sushi or Chinese food options in New Milford NJ?
Yes! Sushi Story is a standout for sushi lovers, while Lantern Chinese and China Wok offer great Chinese takeout.

Q4: Any great breakfast or donut spots in town?
Glaze Donuts is a must for morning cravings, and Big Jim’s is perfect for diner-style breakfasts.

Q5: Is there good late-night or casual food near downtown New Milford?
Barrel & Brew offers casual pub food, while Roman Pizza and Sopranos stay open for evening bites.