The Best Pizza in Bergenfield, NJ (2025 Guide)
Your slice-by-slice tour of Bergenfield’s underrated pizza scene
Bergenfield might not make national headlines for its pizza—but that’s exactly what makes it special. No tourist crowds. No overpriced gimmicks. Just honest, neighborhood pizza made by people who know what a good pie really means.
From crunchy corner slices to bubbling Sicilian squares, this guide takes you straight to Bergenfield’s best. Whether you grew up folding a Brother’s slice or just moved into the 07621 zip code, prepare to meet your new go-to.
1. Brother’s Pizza
85 S Washington Ave, Bergenfield, NJ
There are pizza places… and then there’s Brother’s. A Bergenfield institution, this spot delivers that classic NY-style pizza with zero frills and zero compromises. Thin, foldable, cheesy in the best way—and always hot.
What locals love:
- Giant slices perfect for a quick lunch
- Garlic knots that disappear in seconds
- That sauce… bold, balanced, and a little addictive
2. Pizza Romagna
101 Portland Ave, Bergenfield, NJ
If you like your pizza light, crisp, and kissed by olive oil, Romagna will ruin you for all other pies. The crust is thin and crackly, the mozzarella fresh, and the topping combos feel straight out of a Roman alleyway.
Don’t miss:
- White pie with spinach and garlic
- Sausage and broccoli rabe
- Their signature grandma pie
3. Nick’s Pizza & Pasta
Pizza or pasta? You don’t have to choose. Nick’s is the perfect hybrid—serving up cozy, cheesy comfort in every slice. It’s the kind of spot where kids grab after-school pies and families pick up trays for Sunday dinner.
Go for:
- Chicken bacon ranch
- Eggplant rollatini slice
- A side of baked ziti (trust us)
4. Tony’s Italian Cuisine
127 S Washington Ave, Bergenfield, NJ
Hidden behind its unassuming storefront is a full Italian kitchen—pizzas, pastas, wings, and more. Tony’s pies are crispy on the outside, chewy inside, and piled with toppings that don’t fall off on the first bite.
Local favorites:
- Supreme pie
- Chicken parm pizza
- Buffalo wings on the side
5. Culto Italiano
49 W Church St, Bergenfield, NJ
A newer player with serious chef credentials, Culto brings Neapolitan technique to Bergenfield’s back streets. The pies here are art—fermented dough, charred bubbles, and toppings like truffle oil, burrata, or speck.
Best for:
- Date night or foodie takeout
- Wood-fired margherita
- Fig and prosciutto seasonal specials
6. Bergenfield Pizzeria
344 S Washington Ave, Bergenfield, NJ
This is your no-nonsense, no-shortcuts neighborhood pizzeria. Expect the classics done right—cheese, pepperoni, sausage—with a thin crust that holds its own. Bonus: fast service, perfect for quick pickup.
Great for:
- Classic pepperoni
- Sausage mushroom pie
- Midweek dinner when you don’t want to cook
7. Papa Johns & Pizza Hut
- Papa Johns: 39 Portland Ave, Bergenfield, NJ
- Pizza Hut: 391 S Washington Ave, Bergenfield, NJ
For those who crave the comfort of chains, both Papa Johns and Pizza Hut have Bergenfield covered. Great for late-night cravings, online deals, or feeding a crowd with predictable pies.
Final Thoughts: Pizza That’s Pure Bergenfield
You won’t find viral TikToks or celebrity lines outside these shops—but that’s the point. Bergenfield’s pizza scene is for real people, real families, and real food lovers. From your Tuesday-night takeout to your birthday party go-to, this town has slices that stick with you.
So next time you ask, “Where should we order from?”—start here. Just don’t blame us when you can’t pick a favorite.
FAQs
Q: What is the best pizza place in Bergenfield NJ?
A: Brother’s Pizza is one of the most popular pizzerias in Bergenfield, known for its classic New York-style slices and local neighborhood vibe.
Q: Are there authentic Italian pizza spots in Bergenfield?
A: Yes. Pizza Romagna and Culto Italiano serve thin-crust and wood-fired Italian-style pizzas made with imported ingredients.
Q: Where can I get pizza near 07621 zip code?
A: Bergenfield offers several pizza spots within 07621, including Nick’s Pizza, Bergenfield Pizzeria, and Tony’s Italian Cuisine.
Q: Does Bergenfield have chain pizza places?
A: Yes. Bergenfield is home to Papa John’s and Pizza Hut locations for fast, reliable delivery or takeout.
