East Rutherford may be best known for MetLife Stadium and the American Dream Mall, but locals know it’s also home to a surprisingly vibrant food scene. Whether you’re catching a game, shopping till you drop, or just hungry on the go—this town serves up everything from cozy Italian joints to quick sushi takeout, massive buffets, and build-your-own salad bowls.
Here’s your ultimate 2025 guide to the best restaurants in East Rutherford, NJ—organized by food type and occasion.
Local Favorites That Everyone Talks About
These East Rutherford staples have earned loyal followings for good reason.
- Annabella’s Kitchen
Known for massive sandwiches, Italian specialties, and that old-school Jersey warmth. A go-to lunch spot before the game or after work. - Mr. Pizza East Rutherford
Classic neighborhood pizzeria serving up thin-crust pies, wings, and pasta. Simple, satisfying, and always reliable. - Al Di La Ristorante
White-tablecloth vibes, rich pasta dishes, and an excellent wine list make this the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or special occasion.
Best Pizza & Italian Restaurants
From wood-fired pizzas to comforting classics, these spots have you covered:
- Vesta Wood Fired Pizza & Bar
Not your average pizza joint—this elevated yet casual restaurant serves gourmet pies, pasta, and seasonal apps with craft cocktails. - Papa John’s East Rutherford
If you’re craving something quick and familiar, this national chain is still going strong. - Park Tavern (New Park Tavern)
A neighborhood institution with pub fare, brick oven pizzas, and rotating local beers. Great for groups and casual hangouts.
Top Sushi Spots
Yes, East Rutherford has sushi—and it’s actually excellent.
- Nizi Sushi
A trendy, clean space serving high-quality rolls and beautifully plated entrees. Try their specialty Nizi Roll and tuna tartare. - Samurai Sushi
Cozy and consistently good. Perfect for takeout or a low-key dinner.
Fast-Casual Favorites & Global Eats
Looking for something fast, familiar, or international? These are great for mall breaks or stadium nights.
- Taqueria Los Güeros
Street-style tacos, burritos, and authentic Mexican flavor—fast, filling, and super satisfying. - Panera Bread
For soups, salads, sandwiches, and coffee in a relaxed setting. - Chipotle
You already know. Burrito bowls, tacos, and guac for the win. - Five Guys
Juicy burgers, generous fries, and peanut oil perfection. - Starbucks
Perfect pit stop for your caffeine fix before or after events.
Bowls, Buffets & Health-Conscious Picks
Balance things out or load up your plate—your call.
- Rice Shop
Build-your-own Asian-inspired bowls with fresh veggies, grilled meats, and house sauces. Quick, tasty, and filling. - Flaming Grill & Buffet
Massive buffet with Chinese, American, and hibachi options. Great value, especially for families or big appetites. - Saladworks East Rutherford
A must for clean eaters. Create your own salad or warm grain bowl with a variety of toppings and proteins.
Dining Near MetLife Stadium & American Dream Mall
Whether you’re gearing up for a concert or winding down after a rollercoaster ride, these restaurants are within 5–10 minutes of the stadium and mall:
- Quick Eats: Panera, Five Guys, Starbucks, Chipotle
- Casual Sit-Down: Annabella’s, Vesta Wood Fired Pizza, Park Tavern
- Late-Night Options: Papa John’s, Mr. Pizza, Taqueria Los Güeros (check hours before visiting)
You can also browse restaurants near MetLife Stadium on Google Maps for real-time options and hours.
Final Thoughts
East Rutherford may be compact, but when it comes to food, it punches above its weight. From hearty Italian comfort food to quick burrito bowls and fresh sushi, there’s something here for every taste and timeline.
Whether you’re in town for a Jets game, spending the day at American Dream, or just passing through—you’re definitely not leaving hungry.
