Tenafly Real Estate & Rentals (2025 Guide): Homes, Apartments & Market Insights
Tenafly, NJ, is one of Bergen County’s most sought-after communities. Known for its top-rated public schools, scenic neighborhoods, and proximity to New York City, it consistently ranks among the best places to live in northern New Jersey.
Whether you’re exploring homes for sale in Tenafly, NJ, considering apartments or rentals, or researching the local housing market, this 2025 guide covers it all — from price trends and street-level insights to schools, services, and community life.
Homes for Sale in Tenafly, NJ
Housing Styles You’ll Find
- Historic Colonials & Victorians – Common near Engle Street, Hillside Avenue, and Highwood Avenue.
- Luxury Estates – Found along Knickerbocker Road, East Hill, and Country Club Drive, often priced in the multi-million-dollar range.
- Cape Cods & Split-Levels – Scattered throughout residential areas near Tenafly Road and Oak Avenue, appealing to first-time buyers.
- New Construction – Contemporary builds and luxury townhomes rising near the downtown core and eastern side of town.
2025 Market Snapshot
- Median Home Price: Around $1.3M (well above the Bergen County average).
- Entry-Level Homes: Smaller single-family homes start near $750,000–$900,000.
- Luxury Estates: $2M–$5M+ for properties east of Knickerbocker Rd or in East Hill.
To explore available listings, connect with local Tenafly real estate agents or browse BergenRealEstate.com, which provides the most up-to-date community insights.
Apartments & Rentals in Tenafly
Popular Rental Areas
- Downtown Tenafly (Washington Street & Piermont Road) – Walkable apartments above shops and restaurants.
- Engle Street Corridor – Multi-family homes with rental units.
- Near Knickerbocker Road – Smaller complexes and privately owned rentals.
Rent Prices in 2025
- 1-Bedroom Apartments: $2,100–$2,500/month
- 2-Bedroom Apartments: $2,600–$3,500/month
- Luxury Rentals: $4,000–$6,000/month in newer complexes
Tenafly’s rentals are competitive due to high demand from professionals commuting to NYC and families moving for the school system.
Condos & Townhomes
While Tenafly is primarily a single-family residential town, condos and townhomes do exist:
- Downtown Tenafly – Modern developments close to Piermont Rd with walkable access to shops and restaurants.
- Near Knickerbocker Rd & Clinton Ave – Luxury townhome communities built in the last decade.
These properties offer a lower-maintenance lifestyle while still keeping residents within Tenafly’s excellent school district.
Tenafly Real Estate Market Trends (2025)
- Low Inventory – Homes move quickly, especially in the $1M–$2M range.
- Strong Appreciation – Property values continue to rise 5–7% annually, fueled by demand for schools and proximity to Manhattan.
- Luxury Market Stability – Despite higher interest rates, Tenafly’s luxury estates remain in demand among international buyers and NYC professionals.
- Rental Demand – Consistently strong due to limited supply and school-driven relocations.
Street-Level Note: East Hill properties command the highest premiums, while homes west of Tenafly Road offer more affordability.
Schools: The #1 Driver of Tenafly Housing Demand
Tenafly is widely recognized for its public school system, consistently ranked among the top in New Jersey.
- Tenafly High School – 19 Columbus Dr, Tenafly, NJ (Google Maps)
- Tenafly Middle School – 10 Sunset Ln, Tenafly, NJ (Google Maps)
- Elementary Schools: Mackay, Maugham, Smith, and Stillman — each serving different neighborhoods.
Private education options also exist nearby, including Dwight-Englewood School in Englewood.
Families consistently move to Tenafly for the schools, making real estate here especially competitive.
Parks, Recreation & Community Life
Tenafly Nature Center
313 Hudson Ave, Tenafly, NJ
A 400-acre preserve offering hiking, birdwatching, and educational programs.
Knickerbocker Country Club
188 Knickerbocker Rd, Tenafly, NJ A private golf and social club featuring tennis courts, dining, and swimming.
Tenakill Swim Club
299 Grove St, Tenafly, NJ A private summer swim club popular with families.
Sunnyside Park
40 Sunnyside Ln, Tenafly, NJ A local park with playgrounds, tennis courts, and ball fields.
Essentials: Banks, Services & Shopping
- Chase Bank – 49 Washington St, Tenafly, NJ (Google Maps)
- TD Bank – 45 County Rd, Tenafly, NJ (Google Maps)
- Stop & Shop – 34 County Rd, Tenafly, NJ (Google Maps)
- CVS Pharmacy – 30 Washington St, Tenafly, NJ (Google Maps)
These services contribute to Tenafly’s reputation as a self-contained and convenient community.
Transportation & Commuting
- To NYC: About 12 miles from Midtown Manhattan.
- By Bus: NJ Transit routes run from Tenafly to Port Authority.
- By Train: Nearest stations are in Englewood (Hudson-Bergen Light Rail expansion expected in future).
- By Car: Quick access via Palisades Interstate Parkway and George Washington Bridge.
Tenafly is especially popular with professionals who work in Manhattan but want suburban living.
Key Takeaways for Buyers & Renters
- Expect Competition – Homes sell fast; be pre-approved and ready to act.
- Budget High – Tenafly homes are among the most expensive in Bergen County.
- School District = Value – The school system drives demand and long-term appreciation.
- Luxury Demand Strong – East Hill and Knickerbocker Rd estates remain highly desirable.
- Use Local Experts – Work with Tenafly-based agents and check BergenRealEstate.com for trusted insights.
Final Thoughts
Tenafly is more than just a commuter town — it’s a community built around education, culture, and quality of life. With its tree-lined streets, excellent schools, and easy NYC access, it’s no surprise that Tenafly real estate remains one of Bergen County’s most competitive and desirable markets in 2025.
Whether you’re considering buying a home in Tenafly, renting an apartment, or investing in Bergen County real estate, this guide highlights why Tenafly continues to attract families, professionals, and investors alike.
FAQs – Tenafly Real Estate
Q1. How much does a home cost in Tenafly, NJ?
The median home price is around $1.3M in 2025, with smaller homes starting near $750K and luxury estates exceeding $2M–$5M.
Q2. Are there apartments for rent in Tenafly?
Yes, rentals range from $2,100–$3,500/month, with luxury rentals going higher.
Q3. Is Tenafly good for real estate investment?
Yes, thanks to its schools and consistent buyer demand, Tenafly remains a strong long-term market.
Q4. Which schools serve Tenafly residents?
Tenafly Public Schools (K–12), including Tenafly High School, are among the best in NJ.
Q5. How far is Tenafly from NYC?
About 12 miles, with easy commuting options by bus, car, or nearby train stations.
